He uses statistical evidence to prove that the united states is a nation of inequality, hostility, and separatism. The two nation theory has also led to debate over whether pakistan was intended as a secular homeland for indian muslims or an islamic state, and what role religious minorities should play. The concept was propounded by muhammad ali jinnah in the 1940s on the eve of the winding up of the british rule in india. Oct 11, 2017 definition of two nation theory historical background of two nation theory importance of two nation theory with the perspective of pakistan creation.
Muslims have their own customs, religion, and tradition, and from social and moral points of view, muslims are different from hindus. The angloirish and the two nations theory fri, jun 4, 2004, 01. This dual basis of elections for the two wings of pakistan has, for the moment, averted a political crisis in that state. The study of national varieties is a cornerstone of english studies today. Twonation theory a political doctrine rationalizing the division of india politically into two independent nations india and pakistan. The muslim modernist and reformer sir syed ahmed khan 18171898 was the pioneer of the two nation theory. What is two nation theory and why it is important truth. Genesis of the two nations theory and the quaideazam. Mar 18, 2012 from the twonation theory to postpartition literature a historian, former minister and academic dissect the past. The two nation theory was the basis of the struggle for creation of pakistan which held that hindus and muslims are two separate nations. Pdf two nation theory in the light of the speeches of.
The two nation theory, as adopted by jinnah and the muslim league in 1940, was a mere restatement of the minority problem in national terms and not a clarion call, to use dr ayesha jalals vocabulary, for partition. Like my facebook page or follow me on twitter to get my all analysis and published articles. Analysis of two nations by andrew hacker in andrew hackers book, two nations, hacker argues that blacks and whites live in two different worlds. In it he argued that hindus and muslims were two nations and that these two nations had to work together and share in the governance of their common.
Two nations theory, negotiations on partition of india and. Two nation theory ppsc,css preparation,jobs,notes,news. The basic concept behind two nation theory was muslims and hindus was two separate nations from every expects, so it was the right of muslim to had their own. Pakistan, the product of the twonation theory, is struggling to be a nation, 65 years after conception. From the twonation theory to postpartition literature a historian, former minister and academic dissect the past.
How jinnahs ideology shapes pakistans identity bbc news. Twonation theory simple english wikipedia, the free. Definition of two nation theory historical background of two nation theory importance of two nation theory with the perspective of pakistan creation. The two nation theory means that the hindus and the muslims are two different nations. Sir syed ahmed khan gave the idea of the two nations, allama iqbal dreamed a separate homeland for the muslims in the basis of this theory and jinnah made it a reality. Twonation theory two questions arise out of the pakistan national assemblys decision to introduce joint electorat es in eastern pakistan but to hold elections in western pakistan on the basis of separate electorates. On the basis of two nation theory the quaidiazam demanded the partition of india into two states, a muslim state to be called pakistan and the other hindu india that is bharat. May 03, 2014 the two nation theory was the basis of the struggle for creation of pakistan which held that hindus and muslims are two separate nations. The two nation theory means thecultural, political, religious, economic and socialdissimilarities between the two majorcommunities, hindus and muslims of the subcontinent. In ireland, the two nations theory holds that ulster protestants form a distinct irish nation. Motilal nehru convened an allparty conference in 1929 to suggest changes that would lead to independence when the british.
They in spite of living together for centuries could not forget their individual cultures and civilization. The two nation theory developed through an evolutionary process. In the beginning, one could find the muslims and hindus struggling for supremacy in the battlefield. It states that muslims and hindus are two separate nations from every definition. Advocated mainly by unionists and loyalists, who used it as a basis for opposing home rule and, later, to justify the partition of ireland, it has been strongly criticised by irish nationalists such as john redmond who stated that the two nation theory is to us an abomination and a blasphemy. Analysis of two nations by andrew hacker essay 647 words. The ideology of pakistan stems from the instinct of the muslim community of south asia to maintain their individuality by resisting all attempts by the hindu society to absorb it. It was not considered the solution of problems of muslims in india, it was considered the only way forward. Secularization without secularism in pakistan sciences po. Dec 07, 2011 the two nation theory means that the hindus and the muslims are two different nations. In traditional democracy, the majority party wins the right to govern. Pakistans history has been bleached by official narratives. Pdf two nation theory in the light of the speeches of quidi. Jun 16, 2012 the two nation theory was the basis of the struggle for creation of pakistan which held that hindus and muslims are two separate nations.
Subcontinent consists of two different communitieshaving their own philosophy of life. Pakistan is a state founded on ideological basis and not on territorial grounds. Two nations theory, negotiations on partition of india and pakistan. It is a travesty that congressmen who accepted the islamic demand of a separate state on the basis of religion and leftists who fervently believe india to be a hotchpotch of multiple nationalities, should hurl the charge of advocacy of the twonation theory on savarkar, a lifelong champion of a unified india. It states muslims and hindus are two separate nations by definition. As a result, the first two constitutions of pakistan did not define islam as an. Jinnah, in the frame of his twonation theory, as an identity marker. The muslims are not a community but a nation with a distinctive history, heritage, culture, civilization, and future aspirations. Sir syed ahmad khan and the twonation theory studybix. We have different languages, different histories, our heroes are their villains and vice versa, hindu worship cows, but we muslim slaughter it to eat, they drink the urine of cow, but we say it one of the most dirty things. They in spite of living together for centuries could not forget their individual culture and civilization. This paper is an attempt to show in the light of the speeches of quaidiazam muhammad ali jinnah the meaning and import of two nation theory.
Mar 20, 2012 the ideology of pakistan stems from the instinct of the muslim community of south asia to maintain their individuality by resisting all attempts by the hindu society to absorb it. The twonation theory in its simplest way means that cultural, political, religious, economic and social dissimilarities between the two major communities, hindus and muslims of the subcontinent. Two nation theory a political doctrine rationalizing the division of india politically into two independent nations india and pakistan. The two nation theory means thecultural, political, religious, economic and. Download citation on jan 1, 2018, clinton bennett and others published two nation theory find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. The 193740 period was critical in the growth of the two nations theory. Now, in the prepartition india, hindus were the maj. The over all impact of this theory is that muslims and hindus have different beliefs and their culture. The key point of difference between the two nations is their religion, namely islam and hinduism. May 12, 2012 the two nation theory was the basis of the struggle for creation of pakistan which held that hindus and muslims are two separate nations. The twonation theory is the basis of the creation of pakistan. The two nation theory muhammad ali jinnah south asia. Jul 30, 2011 the two nation theory was the basis of the struggle for creation of pakistan which held that hindus and muslims are two separate nations.
It is a travesty that congressmen who accepted the islamic demand of a separate state on the basis of religion and leftists who fervently believe india to be a hotchpotch of multiple nationalities, should hurl the charge of advocacy of the two nation theory on savarkar, a lifelong champion of a unified india. Hindus and muslims had their distinct religions, culture, civilisation, literature, history and special values. India is not a country but a subcontinent composed of nationalities, the two major nations being. Events in the late 1920s and 1930s led muslims to begin to think that their destiny might be in a separate state, a concept that developed into the demand for partition. In 1934, jinnah returned to the leadership of the muslim league after a period of residence in london, but found it divided and without a sense of mission. Pdf two nation theory in the light of the speeches of quid. The domino theory was a cold war policy that suggested a communist government in one nation would quickly lead to communist takeovers in neighboring states. Starting with the war between muhammad bin qasim and raja dahir in 712, armed conflicts between hindus and muslims run in. Quaideazams struggle also based on twonation theory.
He set about restoring a sense of purpose to muslims, and he emphasised the two nations theory. Two nation theory is the basis of creation of pakistan. Aug 14, 2002 two nation theory is the basis of creation of pakistan. Two nation theory very much alive and repeat where ever muslims and nonmuslims lives, our islamic culture could not be fused with any other culture we muslims are one nation and will reunite where ever our borders are closed.
The two nation theory and demand of pakistan uk essays. One field, world englishes, is entirely founded on the idea that each nation has the freedom to express itself in a unique way through its own type of english. What is the present status of two nation theory in pakistan. The two nation theory georgetown library repository. This theory means that there were two nations in thesubcontinent, the hindus and the muslims. Pakistan day or pakistan resolution day, also republic day, is a national holiday in pakistan commemorating the lahore resolution passed on 23 march 1940 and the adoption of the first constitution of pakistan during the transition of the dominion of pakistan to the islamic republic of pakistan on 23 march 1956 making pakistan the worlds first islamic republic. Pakistans ideology is based on the two nation theory, but the separation of these two nations are not based on ethnicity, language, land but on the religion. The two nation theory in its simplest way means the cultural,political,religious,econo mic and social dissimilarities between the two major communities. Difference in india between the two major nations, the hindus and the muslims are thousand times greater when compared with the continent of europe.
There are a few factors which split the inhabitants of the sub continent into two nations. Two nation theory in the light of the speeches of quaidiazam muhammad ali jinnah. Two nation theory means that muslims and hindus were two separate nations in the subcontinent. Two nation theory played a pivotal role in the creation of pakistan. Yet, the two have failed to develop harmonious relations. Two nation theory was based on facts, that hindu and muslim are completely two nations from every point of view. Importance of two nation theory the twonation theory served as the basis of demand for pakistan by the muslims in british india. He used the word two nations for hindus and muslims once he was convinced of the hindu and congresss hatred and prejudice towards the muslims of the sub continent. Two nation theory sought a formal recognition in the address. Even the usually taciturn army chief has lamented, disillusionment, desperation. Jun 11, 2010 the two nation theory, as adopted by jinnah and the muslim league in 1940, was a mere restatement of the minority problem in national terms and not a clarion call, to use dr ayesha jalals vocabulary, for partition. It clearly stated that the hindus and the muslims are two different nations who cannot be merged into one another in political, religious or even sociocultural way. The subcontinent an infinite multiethnic, multireligious, multiracial and multiclass mass of plurality and a.
The basic concept behind two nation theory was muslims and hindus was two separate nations from every expects, so it was the right of muslim to had their own homeland in the muslims majority areas of subcontinent, where they can live their life according the majestic teachings of islam. Twonation theory is the basis of creation of pakistan. Dec 31, 2015 it was not considered the solution of problems of muslims in india, it was considered the only way forward. Its the only theory in the world where a practical was carried out before the theory could be proved correct and hence the end result being a failed state.
1434 1524 1112 1451 93 86 95 168 905 1046 1396 58 159 1348 905 821 688 1011 1418 1588 1172 933 654 150 49 354 349 939 1028 1131 945 134 1452 8 591